18 Nov

Research Seminar in Decision and Action Theory: Decisions without a state space

Date:

Wed:
10:00 am - 12:00 pm

18 November 2026

Location:

Ludwigstr. 31 Ground floor, room 021 80539 München

Abstract

In the “Savage” model of decision-making under uncertainty, there is a space S of possible “states of nature” (representing the source of uncertainty), and a space X of possible “outcomes”. Each course of action (“act”) is represented as a function from S to X. A rational agent has a utility function on X and (probabilistic) “beliefs” about S, and evaluates each act according to its expected utility.

However, a single agent might encounter many different sources of uncertainty and many different menus of outcomes, which could be combined together into many different decision problems. Furthermore, these different uncertainty sources (or outcome menus) might be related to one another in various ways:

1. There may be analogies between different uncertainty sources (or different outcome menus).

2. At different times, the agent may also have different levels of awareness, or access to different informational resources. Different uncertainty sources (or outcome menus) could represent the agent's subjective perception of the same objective decision problem with different levels of awareness or information.

3. Some uncertainty sources (or outcome menus) might exhibit internal symmetries.

Furthermore, in some situations, the state spaces and outcome spaces have additional mathematical structure (e.g. a topology or differentiable structure), and feasible acts must respect this structure (i.e. they must be continuous or differentiable functions).

Finally (and most important for this presentation), the agent might not have a clear mental representation of the states or outcomes. Instead, she might only have access to observables or measurements that provide indirect, partial information about background conditions, actions, and their consequences (e.g. encoded in a Boolean algebra, Riesz space or some other algebraic structure).

Using tools from category theory, I introduce a modelling framework that addresses all of these issues. I then define and axiomatically characterize subjective expected utility representations in this setting.

Papers:

Speakers

Marcus Pivato (Sorbonne)

Please note

The seminar will take place from 10 to 12 s.t. (please note the start at 10:00) in the MCMP’s larger seminar room (Ludwigstr. 31 / 021).